Review: The Unraveling of Julia by Lisa Scottoline
Looks Like Books contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. If you make a purchase using one of these affiliate links I may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. See my Disclaimer to learn more.
The Unraveling of Julia by Lisa Scottoline is a gothic-tinged thriller that transports readers from heartbreak to the rolling hills of Tuscany. When a young widow inherits a mysterious villa, she steps into a world of family secrets, astrological prophecies, and dangerous conspiracies. Suspenseful, atmospheric, and layered with twists, this novel blends history, romance, and psychological tension into a page-turner that keeps you guessing until the end.
Key Takeaways: The Unraveling of Julia by Lisa Scottoline
What It’s About
Julia Pritzker’s life has been shattered more than once. First, she lost her adoptive parents. Then her husband was murdered, leaving her reeling with grief and convinced she might be cursed. When a cryptic horoscope eerily mirrors her tragedy, Julia begins to wonder if fate has already written her story.
Just as her world feels like it’s slipping away, a letter arrives announcing she’s inherited a villa and vineyard in Tuscany from a woman she’s never heard of – Emilia Rossi. Hoping the estate might hold clues to her biological family, Julia travels to Italy in search of answers.
What she discovers is far from comforting. Emilia Rossi was a recluse obsessed with her supposed ties to Caterina Sforza, the formidable Renaissance noblewoman. Even more unsettling, Julia bears a striking resemblance to both Emilia and Caterina, and soon she notices eerie parallels in their lives.
As she explores the villa and vineyard, Julia begins to suspect someone is watching her. Mysterious accidents and chilling encounters blur the line between coincidence and conspiracy. Caught between the allure of a budding romance and the shadow of danger, Julia must confront secrets from the past before her own unraveling becomes complete.
My Review Rating – 4 out of 5 stars.
A gothic, atmospheric thriller with rich Tuscan settings, chilling twists, and a heroine caught between fate and free will – an engrossing, fast-paced read.
What I Liked
The Setting
Scottoline’s Italian backdrop is lush, atmospheric, and alive with history. The Tuscan villa, vineyard, and even the eerie hints of the poison-touched past add a gothic layer that makes the story feel transportive. I felt completely swept into the Italian countryside, almost like I was there.
The Characters
Julia is a heroine you can’t help but root for. Her grief, insecurities, and gradual transformation into someone who takes control of her own story are compelling and relatable. The enigmatic Emilia Rossi, even in her absence, is a fascinating presence, and the supporting cast – especially the handsome Florentine love interest – adds intrigue and warmth.
The Plot
This is a thriller that weaves personal loss, family secrets, and history together with a sharp gothic edge. I loved the intergenerational mystery, the connections to Caterina Sforza, and how astrology is threaded into Julia’s journey. The suspense is steady and the pacing kept me hooked, with just the right amount of historical detail layered in. The story also ties up its threads neatly, which felt very satisfying for a first read of Scottoline’s work.
What I Disliked
At times, the paranormal and astrological elements felt a little exaggerated and might not work for every reader. A few twists bordered on being a stretch, and the romance developed quickly – more “Hallmark movie” than slow burn. The pacing does dip briefly in the middle, and I can see why some reviews weren’t as enthusiastic, but for me, those moments didn’t take away from the overall experience. Bottom line is – I loved this book.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Unraveling of Julia by Lisa Scottoline
Is The Unraveling of Julia part of a series?
No, it’s a standalone novel, so you can jump right in without having read any of Lisa Scottoline’s other books.
How much of this is thriller vs. romance?
The thriller element drives the story, with conspiracies, secrets, and danger, but the romance adds warmth and hope amid the suspense.
Is astrology really central to the plot?
Yes, astrology and fate play important roles in Julia’s journey. Even if you’re not an astrology fan, it adds an interesting and unique layer to the mystery.
Is this similar to Scottoline’s other books?
This was my first Lisa Scottoline read, and I loved it. From what I’ve seen, she writes across multiple genres – legal thrillers, family dramas, historical fiction – so this gothic-tinged psychological thriller is part of her more recent storytelling evolution.
Conclusion
The Unraveling of Julia by Lisa Scottoline is a gothic thriller that had me hooked from the first chapter. With its atmospheric Tuscan setting, strong heroine, and clever weaving of history, fate, and suspense, it’s a book that lingers long after the last page. While a few twists stretch believability, and the romance is lighter than some readers might expect, I found it an engrossing and satisfying read.
As my first experience with Lisa Scottoline, it definitely won’t be my last – I’ll be looking forward to diving into more of her books soon.
If you enjoy twisty thrillers and suspense with an international backdrop, be sure to check out more Mystery & Thrillers for your next read.
📚 Did You Know?
Caterina Sforza, the Renaissance noblewoman tied to Emilia Rossi’s legacy in this novel, was very real. Known as the “Tiger of Forlì,” she was famous for her political power, resilience, and rumored involvement with alchemy and astrology – making her a fascinating historical inspiration for this modern thriller.
