The Midnight Library by Matt Haig: Book Review
Looks Like Books contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. If you make a purchase using one of these affiliate links I may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. See my Disclaimer to learn more.
If you’re wondering whether The Midnight Library by Matt Haig lives up to the hype, the short answer is yes, especially if you’ve ever stayed up late pondering the “what-ifs” in your life.
This genre-blending bestseller is part speculative fiction, part emotional deep dive, and it’s struck a nerve with readers everywhere.
It’s also a Read With Jenna book club pick and a frequent flyer on “books that make you think” lists – for good reason.
My Take: The Midnight Library gave me exactly the kind of thoughtful, slightly unusual story I hoped for. I loved the idea of exploring all those “what if?” versions of a life, and although a few of the philosophical points felt a little too tidy, the book still gave me plenty to think about after I finished it. My Verdict? Read.
What It’s About
Imagine a library where every book provides a chance to try another life you could have lived. Welcome to The Midnight Library!
At her lowest moment, Nora Seed finds herself transported to a mysterious in-between place called the Midnight Library. Each book in the library offers her the chance to undo regrets and try a different version of her life. What follows is an exploration of possibility, purpose, and what makes life worth living.
The Midnight Library by Matt Haig – What I Liked
Matt Haig’s The Midnight Library blends magical realism with deep philosophical questions about regret, choice, and the meaning of life. In this review, I’ll walk through the aspects that made this novel so impactful, the parts that felt less effective, and why it continues to resonate with so many readers worldwide.
The Setting
The concept of the Midnight Library itself is haunting, magical, and just the right amount of eerie. It’s both fantastical and grounded, providing a powerful metaphor for the space between life and death.
The Characters
Nora is incredibly relatable. Her self-doubt and yearning for meaning reflect a universal struggle, and her journey feels personal yet expansive. Supporting characters (especially Mrs. Elm) are memorable, even in their fleeting appearances.
The Plot & Storylines
Though introspective, the novel keeps a strong pace. Each “what-if” life is compelling and distinct. The structure helps maintain curiosity without being confusing or repetitive.
The Midnight Library – What I Didn’t Like
A few of the alternate lives felt a bit rushed or too neat, especially toward the end. Readers who prefer hard-hitting realism might find the philosophical optimism a bit too tidy.
The Midnight Library – Read, ReRead, or Reconsider?
Read.
Frequently Asked Questions About The Midnight Library
Is The Midnight Library a fantasy novel?
The Midnight Library is generally considered speculative fiction, with fantasy and magical-realism elements. Its unusual premise is really a framework for exploring regret, choice, and the different directions a life can take.
Is this a good book for book clubs?
Absolutely. With its unique structure and big life questions, this novel sparks all kinds of discussion – from regrets and second chances to mental health and personal growth. Plus, it’s already been featured as a Read With Jenna book club pick, so there’s plenty of supplemental material available for clubs.
What genre is The Midnight Library?
It’s a blend of contemporary fiction, speculative fiction, and philosophical drama. While technically grounded in realism, the concept of a library between life and death gives it a slightly fantastical edge, perfect for readers who enjoy thoughtful fiction with a twist.
Is The Midnight Library by Matt Haig Worth Reading?
Yes, in my opinion, it’s not one to miss. And I’m glad my book club finally got to this book.
This novel will hit especially hard if you’ve ever asked yourself “what if?” – and honestly, who hasn’t? With its deeply human questions wrapped in a lightly magical package, The Midnight Library is perfect for readers who enjoy a side of soul-searching with their fiction.
And, if your book club is reading this right now or in the future, grab these book club questions for The Midnight Library.
What To Read Next
- Remarkably Bright Creatures by Shelby Van Pelt – Another thoughtful, hopeful novel about grief, connection, and second chances, with an unusual premise and a lot of heart.
- The Echo of Old Books by Barbara Davis – A good choice if you liked the slightly magical, bookish quality of The Midnight Library. It combines an unusual book-centered premise with love, loss, forgiveness, and second chances.
- The Measure by Nikki Erlick – Probably the closest thematic match: a speculative “what would you do?” premise that gets readers thinking about life, choices, and how we decide what makes a life meaningful. You already have it included in your Read With Jenna material, so it gives us another natural internal-link opportunity.
