Witchy Books: 10 Spellbinding Reads From Cozy to Gothic
Looks Like Books contains affiliate links and is a member of the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. If you make a purchase using one of these affiliate links I may receive compensation at no extra cost to you. See my Disclaimer to learn more.
If your reading mood lives somewhere between candlelight and cauldrons, these witchy books deliver. You’ll find cozy charm, found family, prickly romance, and darker threads pulled from history and folklore – stories where power, community, and consequence all have a little magic in them.
Key Takeaways: Witchy Books & Spellbinding Reads
Witchy Books For Spellbinding Reads
This mix spans contemporary covens, historical trials, and fairy-tale-adjacent fantasy. Expect atmosphere over gore, grown-up themes handled with warmth or bite, and plenty of picks that work for book clubs or a curl-up evening.
Practical Magic — Alice Hoffman
Sisterhood, small-town suspicion, and a family magic that keeps tugging the Owens women toward fate. Lush, bittersweet, and eminently rereadable.
A Discovery of Witches — Deborah Harkness
An Oxford scholar witch unlocks a forbidden manuscript and collides with a vampire geneticist. Academia, alchemy, slow-burn romance.
The Witch’s Heart — Genevieve Gornichec
Loki’s witch falls in love and fights for her children in a Norse-myth retelling. Intimate, mythic, and full of fierce tenderness.
The Lighthouse Witches — C.J. Cooke
A Scottish island, missing girls, and a lighthouse where centuries-old witch lore refuses to stay buried. Gothic mood with a modern pulse.
The Witches of New York — Ami McKay
Victorian Manhattan teashop witches navigate faith healers, frauds, and true peril. Feminist, atmospheric, and wonderfully bookish.
Uprooted — Naomi Novik
A village girl’s unexpected magic meets a corrupted forest—and a prickly mentor. Fairy-tale bones with rich, original worldbuilding.
Garden Spells — Sarah Addison Allen
An enchanted family garden nudges people toward the lives they need. Soft magic, community, a gentle romance—pure comfort.
Serpent & Dove — Shelby Mahurin
A witch and a witch-hunter are bound by marriage in a French-tinged fantasy. Banter, chemistry, and sharp stakes (YA crossover).
The Witchfinder’s Sister — Beth Underdown
During England’s witch-hunt era, a woman returns to her brother—the notorious witchfinder—and sees what zealotry costs. Chilling historical lens.
Her Majesty’s Royal Coven — Juno Dawson
Four childhood friends in Britain’s top secret coven confront power, politics, and change. Modern, funny, and pointed with heart.
Frequently Asked Questions About These Witchy Books
I want cozy comfort – where should I start?
Garden Spells is warm and low-stakes; for romance-forward magic, Serpent & Dove and A Discovery of Witches both deliver swoony tones with action.
What if I prefer something moodier or gothic?
Try The Lighthouse Witches for an eerie coastal atmosphere or The Witchfinder’s Sister for a historical chill anchored in real witch-hunt terror.
Are these all adult books?
Mostly. Serpent & Dove reads YA/crossover; the rest are primarily adult, with a range from gentle to darker themes.
Do I need the series order for any of these?
Her Majesty’s Royal Coven and Serpent & Dove kick off series, but work as strong entry points. Practical Magic stands alone; if you’re curious, its prequel, The Rules of Magic, is lovely later.
Any audio standouts?
Practical Magic and A Discovery of Witches shine on audio for voice and atmosphere.
Conclusion
Build a two-book stack to match your mood: pair a cozy comfort like Garden Spells with a moodier pick such as The Lighthouse Witches, or go romance-forward with A Discovery of Witches alongside the sharp, modern energy of Her Majesty’s Royal Coven. When you’re ready for a mythic sweep, save The Witch’s Heart or Uprooted for a weekend dive.
So, we know that witches make an appearance around Halloween. Which is also a great time for gothic fiction, in my opinion. Or, maybe you’re just in the mood for some good fall vibes. Whatever the case may be, you’ll find lots of seasonal stuff on our Seasonal & Gift Guide page.
